PBF vs VLO
PBF Energy and Valero Energy, side by side.
Prices and company dataas of yesterday's close
- PBFBuy morein the past month−17%
PBF Energy fell 17% over the past month while other oil and gas stocks barely moved, but its report on Oct 29 beat profit forecasts by 13%.
- VLOBuy morein the past month−16%
Valero Energy fell 16% over the past month while other oil and gas stocks barely moved, but its report on Oct 22 beat profit forecasts by 12%.
Percent return
- PBF+77.79%
- VLO+105.36%
Nov 11, 2025 to Nov 11, 2026
Where they differ
- Company size: PBF $7.50B, VLO $89.8B.
- Sales growth, 1 yr: PBF +32%, VLO +26%. PBF is ahead.
- Price for $1 of next year's profit: PBF $3, VLO $6. PBF is ahead.
- Profit per $1 of sales: PBF 7¢, VLO 12¢. VLO is ahead.
- Cash minus debt: PBF −$167M, VLO −$1.16B. PBF is ahead.
- Price change, 1 yr: PBF +78%, VLO +105%. VLO is ahead. S&P 500 +12%.
- How much the price swings: PBF 69%, VLO 42%. VLO is ahead.
| Measure | PBFPBF Energy | VLOValero Energy |
|---|---|---|
| Price and returns | ||
| Price | $69.71 | $363.64 |
| Today | Best in this row: +5.77% | +3.69% |
| 1 month | −17.25% | Best in this row: −16.15% |
| 3 months | +0.89% | Best in this row: +12.26% |
| This year | Best in this row: +161.87% | +126.73% |
| 1 year | +77.79% | Best in this row: +105.36% |
| 5 years | +423.38% | Best in this row: +449.84% |
| From 52-week high | −23.5% | −20.9% |
| How much it swings (90 days) | 69% | Best in this row: 42% |
| Valuation | ||
| Market value | $7.50B | $89.8B |
| Price vs last year's earnings | Best in this row: 16.7× | 22.1× |
| Price vs next year's expected earnings | Best in this row: 2.6× | 5.5× |
| Price vs earnings, adjusted for growth | – | 0.74× |
| Price to sales | Best in this row: 0.2× | 0.7× |
| Price vs cash it brings in | Best in this row: 3.2× | 6.4× |
| Company value vs operating profit | Best in this row: 2.8× | 4.7× |
| Price vs earnings, against its own past (0 = cheapest) | 98 | Best in this row: 88 |
| Growth | ||
| Revenue growth, 1 year | Best in this row: +31.5% | +25.7% |
| Revenue growth a year, last 3 years | −14.4% | Best in this row: −12.2% |
| Earnings per share growth, last year | +141.6% | Best in this row: +385.0% |
| Earnings per share growth expected next year | −24.6% | Best in this row: −11.7% |
| Profitability | ||
| Kept from sales after making the product | 9.9% | Best in this row: 19.5% |
| Kept as operating profit | 7.1% | Best in this row: 12.2% |
| Kept as final profit | 7.0% | Best in this row: 8.8% |
| Kept as spare cash | 6.6% | Best in this row: 10.3% |
| Profit on shareholders' money | 40.6% | Best in this row: 46.9% |
| Profit on all money put in | 25.3% | Best in this row: 43.4% |
| Balance sheet | ||
| Net cash (cash minus debt) | Best in this row: −$167M | −$1.16B |
| Debt for each $1 of shareholders' money | Best in this row: 0.33× | 0.35× |
| Short-term assets per $1 of bills due | 1.59× | Best in this row: 1.72× |
| Dividend yield | Best in this row: 1.93% | 1.39% |
| Share of profit paid as dividends | Best in this row: 5% | 11% |
| Our readPro | ||
| Our call | Buy more | Buy more |
| Why | PBF Energy fell 17% over the past month while other oil and gas stocks barely moved, but its report on Oct 29 beat profit forecasts by 13%. | Valero Energy fell 16% over the past month while other oil and gas stocks barely moved, but its report on Oct 22 beat profit forecasts by 12%. |
| Where the price sits | in the full report | in the full report |
| Our overall score (out of 100) | 50 | Best in this row: 55 |
| Our value score | Best in this row: 62 | 40 |
| Our growth score | 48 | Best in this row: 52 |
| Our quality score | 46 | Best in this row: 65 |
| Our price trend score | 46 | Best in this row: 64 |
| Earnings and analysts | ||
| Analyst consensus | Hold | Buy |
| To average analyst target | +16.8% | Best in this row: +22.8% |
| Average analyst target | $81.45 | $446.53 |
| Analysts rating it a buy | 7% | Best in this row: 45% |
| Buy ratings added, 3 months | Best in this row: 0 | −1 |
| Analysts covering | 11 | 17 |
VLO: wider profit margins and more analyst upside
Our pick of these: Valero Energy
Keeps 12.2% of sales as operating profit, vs 7.1%
PBF 7.1%, VLO 12.2%.+22.8% to the average analyst target, vs +16.8%
PBF +16.8%, VLO +22.8%.45% of analysts rate it a buy, vs 7%
PBF 7%, VLO 45%.Where it loses: PBF has faster sales growth, +31.5% vs +25.7%
Cover this stock to see the full report
The call, its reasons and what would change it are free for everyone. The price zones, the whole brief and how the call has moved come with covering a stock. Use one of your three covered slots, or go Pro for every stock.
Prices as of yesterday, 3:59 PM ET. A view, not advice.