Rebalancing and tax-loss ideas
How the ideas page decides what to sell for size, where the money could go, which losses could be sold for tax, and what the tax figures assume.
2 min read
Open the ideasOn this page5 sections
The ideas page works out, from your holdings and our calls, whether anything is too big for the portfolio and which losses could be sold for tax. These are ideas from the numbers, not advice and not tax advice. Nothing on the page buys or sells; any trade is yours to make at your broker.
When a stock is too big
- A company is over the line at 10% of the portfolio, counting what your funds hold of it.
- A trim sells back to the line, at most half the holding, for the three biggest companies over it. Any others over the line are named, not sized.
- A sector more than 15 points above its S&P 500 weight, or a stock that has grown to well past its share of the money put in, can get a trim too.
- No trim sells a stock our call says to keep or buy more of. Those are shown over the line with no sale.
- We leave out any sale under $500 or under 2 points of the portfolio: too small to be worth the trade.
- Funds are never trimmed. They are already spread out.
Where the money could go
The money raised goes, on paper, only to stocks our call says to buy more of, in sectors that are not already heavy, up to 8% of the portfolio each, and never to a stock listed as a loss to sell. Whatever is left is shown as cash.
Losses you could sell for tax
- A loss shows when a holding is at least 5% and $100 below what was paid.
- The tax saved assumes you have gains to set the loss against.
- The wash-sale rule: if you buy the same stock, or one that is substantially identical, within 30 days before or after selling it at a loss, the loss is put off until you sell the new shares. Each loss card shows the first day it is safe to buy back.
- The look-alikes are similar by our data (same industry and size for a stock, shared holdings for a fund), not a recommendation. They will not move exactly the same way.
What the tax figures assume
- US federal rules made simple: the two rates you pick, no state tax, and the oldest shares sold first.
- Short-term gains (held a year or less) are taxed like income, so pick your bracket. Long-term gains are taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%; 15% is the usual one.
- Where you entered lots on the Taxes page we use them. Otherwise a holding counts from the day you saved it, at its average cost, so shares bought earlier may already be long term, and a holding with no cost gets no estimate.
- We do not see your whole tax year.
The bars under each stock
Each card shows the stock's sales growth over four quarters, its five-day move against similar companies, and its P/E against its usual level. A labelled tick marks the level our call is measured against, and the line under it says it in words.
Read next
- Adding holdingsThe difference between holding and watching, what to enter for a holding, and what the product does with it.
- Portfolio analyticsWhat the figures under your holdings work out, how each one is computed and what it leaves out.
- Where the data comes from and how fresh it isEvery data set in the product, its source, how to tell how old it is and what it does not cover.
Something here wrong or unclear? Tell us. Informational only, not investment advice.