ALL vs CINF

• ALLBuy more39%

  Allstate's report on Nov 4 beat profit forecasts by 39%, and it pays a 1.7% dividend that it has raised for 15 years in a row.

• CINFKeepin the past month+16%

  Cincinnati Financial rose 16% over the past month, in step with other insurers (up 14%), but two fewer analysts rate it a buy than three months ago.

Percent return

• ALL+28.88%
• CINF+16.81%

1M6MYTD1Y5YMax

Nov 11, 2025 to Nov 11, 2026

Where they differ

CINF leads on 4 of 6

ALLCINF

• Company size: ALL $65.3B, CINF $27.8B.
  $65.3BbiggerCompany size$27.8B
• Sales growth, 1 yr: ALL +5.1%, CINF +9.9%. CINF is ahead.
  +5.1%Sales growth, 1 yr+9.9%
• Price for $1 of next year's profit: ALL $9, CINF $21. ALL is ahead.
  $9cheaperPrice for $1 of next year's profit$21
• Profit per $1 of sales: ALL 22¢, CINF 25¢. CINF is ahead.
  22¢Profit per $1 of sales25¢
• Cash minus debt: ALL −$6.95B, CINF +$364M. CINF is ahead.
  −$6.95BCash minus debt+$364M
• Price change, 1 yr: ALL +29%, CINF +17%. ALL is ahead. S&P 500 +12%.
  +29%Price change, 1 yr+17%
• How much the price swings: ALL 30%, CINF 23%. CINF is ahead.
  30%How much the price swingssteadier23%

Measure	ALLAllstate	CINFCincinnati Financial
Price and returns
Price	$262.19	$189.84
Today	Best in this row: +0.41%	−0.03%
1 month	+14.27%	Best in this row: +16.15%
3 months	+0.40%	Best in this row: +10.23%
This year	Best in this row: +27.79%	+18.20%
1 year	Best in this row: +28.88%	+16.81%
5 years	Best in this row: +157.37%	+75.01%
From 52-week high	−4.3%	−0.6%
How much it swings (90 days)	30%	Best in this row: 23%
Valuation
Market value	$65.3B	$27.8B
Price vs last year's earnings	Best in this row: 5.6×	10.4×
Price vs next year's expected earnings	Best in this row: 8.9×	20.5×
Price vs earnings, adjusted for growth	–	6.22×
Price to sales	Best in this row: 0.9×	2.1×
Price vs cash it brings in	Best in this row: 5.0×	9.3×
Company value vs operating profit	Best in this row: 4.5×	8.0×
Growth
Revenue growth, 1 year	+5.1%	Best in this row: +9.9%
Revenue growth a year, last 3 years	+9.6%	Best in this row: +24.4%
Earnings per share growth, last year	Best in this row: +209.6%	+90.9%
Earnings per share growth expected next year	−24.7%	Best in this row: −0.2%
Profitability
Kept as operating profit	21.7%	Best in this row: 25.2%
Kept as final profit	16.4%	Best in this row: 20.1%
Kept as spare cash	18.1%	Best in this row: 23.2%
Profit on shareholders' money	Best in this row: 38.9%	16.9%
Profit on all money put in	Best in this row: 29.6%	15.6%
Balance sheet
Net cash (cash minus debt)	−$6.95B	Best in this row: $364M
Debt for each $1 of shareholders' money	0.23×	Best in this row: 0.05×
Short-term assets per $1 of bills due	0.42×	Best in this row: 1.05×
Dividend yield	1.70%	Best in this row: 2.03%
Share of profit paid as dividends	Best in this row: 10%	22%
Our readPro
Our call	Buy more	Keep
Why	Allstate's report on Nov 4 beat profit forecasts by 39%, and it pays a 1.7% dividend that it has raised for 15 years in a row.	Cincinnati Financial rose 16% over the past month, in step with other insurers (up 14%), but two fewer analysts rate it a buy than three months ago.
Where the price sits	in the full report	in the full report
Our overall score (out of 100)	62	Best in this row: 63
Our value score	Best in this row: 72	38
Our growth score	39	Best in this row: 64
Our quality score	Best in this row: 88	85
Our price trend score	64	Best in this row: 65
Earnings and analysts
Analyst consensus	Hold	Buy
To average analyst target	Best in this row: +4.3%	+1.0%
Average analyst target	$273.56	$191.67
Analysts rating it a buy	Best in this row: 40%	25%
Buy ratings added, 3 months	Best in this row: 0	−2
Analysts covering	16	4

ALL: our only Buy more of these

Our pick of these: Allstate

Buy more68/100

Forward P/E per point of sales growth 1.76 vs 2.07

ALL 1.76, CINF 2.07.

ALL1.76

CINF2.07

+4.3% to the average analyst target, vs +1.0%

ALL +4.3%, CINF +1.0%.

ALL+4.3%

CINF+1.0%

1-year return +28.9% vs +16.8%, S&P 500 +12.4%

ALL +28.9%, CINF +16.8%.

ALL+28.9%

CINF+16.8%

Where it loses: CINF has faster sales growth, +9.9% vs +5.1%

• 2ndCINFKeep32/100Would need our call to move up from Keep

Prices as of yesterday, 3:59 PM ET. A view, not advice.